America is Not the Heart by Elaine Castillo: Home is not necessarily where the heart is

Cover imagePerhaps because I’ve only lived in one country, I’m perennially attracted to the immigrant experience in fiction which is why Elaine Castillo’s debut caught my eye. Set in the Californian city of Milpitas in the early ‘90s, it’s about a Filipino community and I’m ashamed to say that before I read it I knew next to nothing about the Philippines’ troubled history. Castillo explores that history through the story of Hero who comes to live with her uncle and aunt after being released from a prison camp.

Hero hasn’t spoken to her parents since 1976 when she dropped out of medical school and became involved with the New People’s Army. Never part of their guerrilla attacks, Hero patched up her comrades until she was snatched and incarcerated for two years, leaving her with badly broken hands. Her favourite uncle offers her a home in the States where she’s an illegal and unable to work. Instead, she looks after her sassy seven-year-old niece Roni of whom she becomes increasingly fond. Her aunt is not so welcoming. Paz takes as many nursing shifts as she can, stubbornly intent on Roni’s betterment while Pol works as a security guard, his impeccable surgical reputation useless without accreditation. Paz and Pol come from very different backgrounds: he’s from a wealthy family with connections to President Marcos; she’s from a dirt poor, hardscrabble home. Their mother tongues are not the same; their food preferences differ widely; despite her training Paz holds firm to the old superstitions. Paz proudly stood her ground against the womanising Pol for a long time but he was determined. Now their marriage seems unequal. This is the strained household into which Hero must fit herself, made easier when she meets Rosalyn and finds a second home.

America is Not the Heart is a big, sometimes baggy novel that draws you in after a slowish start. Castillo deftly weaves the benighted history of the Philippines into Hero’s story both through flashbacks and family history. Pol and Paz neatly personify the archipelago’s intensely stratified society, a chasm between their ethnic, social and economic backgrounds which seems impossible to bridge although it’s Paz who’s the breadwinner in their American household. Castillo captures the insularity of a community in which the many signals of where each member sits in Filipino society are present and correct, evoking it particularly vividly in Rosalyn’s fury at her own ignorance when she contemplates moving out of Milpitas. The characterisation is strong – Hero and Rosalyn are polar opposites yet their relationship feels entirely credible. And Castillo writes about sex well, unafraid to use a bit of humour – not an easy feat to pull off as winners of the Bad Sex Award will no doubt tell you. Just one criticism, I could have done with a glossary. Lots of googling interrupted the reading flow for me. That said, Castillo’s debut is entertaining, engrossing and enlightening. Can’t say better than that.

6 thoughts on “America is Not the Heart by Elaine Castillo: Home is not necessarily where the heart is”

  1. A graphic memoir that i read recently added to my understanding of Filipino history a little (Duran Duran Imelda Marcos and Me by Lorina Mapa). It’s pretty great to be able to learn history while reading fiction and/or comics, I’d say! This one sounds good to me; I don’t mind baggy when I am caught up with the characters. The cover doesn’t grab me, but the other version of it is more welcoming (and they make a nice pair actually)!

    1. It’s certainly an enjoyable way to find out about the world. I agree about the cover. It wouldn’t have made me want to read the book had I not heard about it already which is a shame.

  2. It sounds very absorbing. This area/period of history is a bit of a black hole for me too. I often think fiction can shine a light on these issues in a different (possibly more accessible?) way to non-fiction books or journalism. I’m thinking in particular of a couple of books I’ve read that were set against the backdrop of Argentina’s Dirty War in the 1970s, one of which (The Memory Stones) was a book group choice. This could suit that market too, especially once it moves into paperback.

    1. Yes, I think you’re right about the light that fiction can shed, Jacqui. The Memory Stones looks well worth investigating. Argentina is another country of which I’m shamefully ignorant.

  3. It’s a difficult task to mix in politics/history with a compelling character-led story, but it sounds like Castillo manages it. I don’t know much about this period either so I’m very tempted by this!

Leave a comment ...

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.