Loyalties by Delphine de Vigan (transl. George Miller): Silence is not always golden

Cover imageI read Delphine de Vigan’s Based on a True Story around this time last year and knew it would be one of my books of the year. I was delighted, then, when I spotted Loyalties on the publishing horizon. It tells the story of a young boy, caught up in the fallout from a bitter divorce, and explores the ties of silence that bind society together in a sometimes mistaken loyalty.

Hélène is a teacher with her eye on Théo. He’s too quiet for a twelve-year-old boy, seems exhausted much of the time and has only one friend. She’s convinced he’s being abused, just as she was as a child when she was subjected to systematic beatings by her sadistic father. She begins an investigation, first through official channels then stepping over the line. Théo spends alternate weeks with his mother and father. His mother is consumed with an entrenched hatred while his father slides into a deep depression. Théo has found an escape, drinking with his friend Mathis in the hope of obliterating his pain and anxiety. Meanwhile Mathis’ mother, Cécile, has discovered that her husband has an online identity that fills her with horror. In this brief novella, de Vigan examines how children can lose their way when the adults around them have lost theirs.

De Vigan tells her story from the perspectives of her four main characters giving a first-person immediacy to both Hélène and Cécile, one caught up in her own history the other reeling back from the discovery of her husband’s vile opinions. Silence and compromise are the themes here: Cécile has allowed herself to be remodeled into the person her husband wants her to be; Mathis can’t reveal Théo’s father’s condition because it will humiliate his friend and Hélène’s mother failed to step in to prevent her beatings. Théo’s situation is heart-wrenching, caught between two adults, more parent than child to one of them. De Vigan’s writing is as pinpoint sharp as ever but my expectations were sky-high after Based on a True Story which was breathtakingly good, not a description I use very often smacking as it does of hyperbole. Unfair to make that comparison given how very different in style and subject the two novels are, but inevitable, I’m afraid.

21 thoughts on “Loyalties by Delphine de Vigan (transl. George Miller): Silence is not always golden

  1. clodge2013

    I read Nothing Holds Back the Night by Delphine de Vigan in April, and although I was impressed by the passion of the writing and by the woman featured, the author’s mother, who had mental health difficulties, it has not left me with the desire to read more of her work. Perhaps I’ll review that after noting your comments on Loyalties.

    Caroline (Bookword)

    Reply
      1. JacquiWine

        Just adding my voice to those recommendations of Nothing Holds Back the Night. It’s an excellent book, both thoughtful and compelling. Definitely worth checking out at some point.

        Reply
  2. Claire 'Word by Word'

    I hesitated with this one, didn’t seem to be quite up to her last two and with so many good but yet to be discovered reads on my shelf, I thought I’d leave this one and try another French title instead.

    Reply
    1. Susan Osborne Post author

      I enjoyed it, Claire, but I think you’ve made the right decision. It tackled some important issues very skilfully but Based on a True Story had raised expectations for something more.

      Reply
  3. juliana brina

    Great review, Susan! ‘Based on A True Story’ was a great read for me last summer, and I’ve been considering to read ‘Nothing Holds Back the Night’ next. Now I am curious for this new novel, too.

    Reply
    1. Susan Osborne Post author

      Thanks, Juliana. Based on a true Story blew my socks off! The general consensus of the comments here seems to be that Nothing Holds Back the Night is excellent, too.

      Reply
  4. Liz

    I have just collected Based on a True Story from the library and am looking forward to it very much, given your enthusiasm for de Vigan’s writing!

    Reply

Leave a comment ...

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.