The premise of Heather Marshall’s Looking for Jane immediately appealed to me: the chance discovery of a misdelivered letter sets the woman who stumbled upon it on a quest to find the addressee, long since gone elsewhere. Marshall uses this trigger to explore the underground networks that existed in both Canada and the USA providing safe but illegal abortions before it was decriminalised. As she points out in her author’s note, her novel is about motherhood and choice rather than abortion.
What would a professional virgin know about being pregnant?
Angela comes across the letter, overlooked in a pile of used books for seven years, addressed to Nancy Mitchell who once lived in the flat above the Toronto shop where she works. On opening it, she finds a heartfelt confession from Nancy’s adoptive mother who had never told Nancy of her status, striking a chord in Angela who is adopted herself. She sets about trying to track down Nancy, distracting herself from her attempts to become pregnant much to the disapproval of her wife. Wind back to 1961 when Evelyn is waiting for the birth of her child in St Agnes’ Home for Unwed Mothers, knowing that she will be forced to give up this much wanted baby. She and her roommate Margaret help each other bear the nuns’ cruelty until the two are separated by the births of their daughters. Two decades later, Nancy learns the hard way how devastating an illegal abortion can be when her cousin becomes pregnant. By the time she has her own unwanted pregnancy to deal with, she’s learnt to ask for Jane, the codeword that will lead her to a sympathetic doctor risking a criminal record and, increasingly, their life, in order to keep women safe. So grateful is Nancy, she volunteers as a counsellor until the day in 1988 when abortion is finally legalised in Canada. After several twists and turns, all three women’s narratives are satisfyingly drawn together.
It all comes down to having the right to make the choice
This is such an engrossing story and such an enlightening own, too. Marshall skilfully switches perspectives between the three women as she unfolds each of their stories, exploring the many and various reproductive choices, which have not always been open to women, in all their complexity, from Angela’s experiences of IVF to Clara’s narrow escape at the hands of a back street abortionist and the forced adoption of Evelyn’s child. It’s overarching theme is the necessity for choice. Such an important word: I’ve always felt frustrated at the use of language around the issue of abortion – I’m passionately pro-choice and resent being called pro-abortion with all that implies. The cruelty of the mother and baby homes is, of course, no surprise but, as ever, it shocks in its universality. Marshall’s novel tells such an immersive, moving story, and tells it so well. Her lengthy author’s note is well worth reading both for context and for her own very personal view.
Hodder Studio: London 9781529364125 400 pages Hardback (read via NetGalley)
That’s it for me for a week. H and I are off to explore Manchester, meet a couple of old friends and maybe visit a few bookshops. I will, of course, be taking an umbrella.
Many thanks for this coverage, and I hear you on every word.
You’re welcome, Jennifer. Such an important issue.
This sounds important, thanks for sharing your thoughts
You’re welcome. Yes, it is and wrapped up in a brilliant piece of storytelling.
I read a book last Fall that was about Jane. It was longlisted for the Giller. We, Jane by Aimee Wall. Before that, I hadn’t known about it.
I like that this one has three storylines.
I also just recently read two books that involved being sent away to have babies and coming home without them. One took place in the 1870s and one in the 1970s. I guess not a lot had changed on that front in those 100 years.
It’s such a great piece of storytelling! Interesting that two writers picked up on the Jane theme.
Desperate, isn’t it? I heard a few interviews with women a while ago who’d been forced to give up their child in the ’70s and was shocked. I had no idea it had gone on for so long.
I can’t even imagine it.
The cruelty of it, and in the name of religion.
What a great premise. Sounds like an excellent read.
That premise hooked me from the start. Highly recommend it!
Such an enticing premise. I had no idea abortion had only been legal in Canada since 1988. Have a lovely time in Manchester!
Me, neither, and thank you. We’re off tomorrow just as the weather changes!
A really enticing premise. This sounds like a very emotive story, but a thoroughly important one too.
It’s such an involving story and, as you say, an important one, too.
Such an important issue. Will have to get this when it’s out in paperback.
Isn’t it, and handled by Marshall in such a clever way.
I know I’ve said this in an earlier post, but I definitely want to read this one!
I hope you enjoy it when you get to it, Marcie. I had no idea about the Jane network but it sounds extraordinarily effective.