This Is Not About Us by Allegra Goodman: ‘This has nothing to do with cake’  

Cover image for This Is Not About Us by Allegra Godman I reviewed Allegra Goodman’s The Chalk Artist here almost a decade ago, noting that it didn’t match up to The Cookbook Collector which I read pre-blog and loved. That said, I was delighted when her new one popped through my letterbox. This Is Not About Us follows a family in which the two surviving Rubinstein sisters embark on a silence that one is desperate to break, while the other stubbornly digs her heels in.

After all people liked sweet things. Anything sweet and easy, simple, fast. Whether in music, or in food, or life, the bitter, dark, and complicated could not compete.

As their adored younger sister lies on her deathbed, taking her time about it, Helen delivers a constant stream of baked goods fallen upon by the family as they come to say their goodbyes. One day, Sylvia has the temerity to bring an apple cake which puts Helen’s in the shade. When Jeanne finally dies, neither sister can agree what she wanted to mark her passage sparking a feud which becomes legendary in the family. Middle sister Sylvia, now the youngest, is left bereft, while Helen maintains her stony silence. Over the years, birthdays, Thanksgivings, a birth, a bat mitzvah and a bris are all marked, Helen conspicuously absent from all of them even when her children are present. Sylvia remains desperate to break the silence, constantly reminded of her sister and how much she adores her, longing to share the pleasures of life but Helen is obdurate, avoiding her sister at all costs.

Jill knew all about Wendy’s strange and estranged family – their unspoken expectations, silent feuds, exhausting birthdays. And yet Wendy was always rushing to their deathbeds and sending hats and letters, even cardigans.

Goodman’s book reads like a set of tightly interwoven short stories as it charts the years after Jeanne’s death, various characters taking centre stage in each chapter. Their lives are marked by rites of passage, troubles with children, redundancy, divorce, new relationships and the beginning of a new family branch: the usual problems, joys and life events, recounted with wit and empathy. Goodman’s narrative is laced with an affectionate humour balanced by poignant moments; her sharply observed characters are engaging, exasperating and endearing, as family members so often are. Throughout it all, Helen’s absence remains, a painful blight on Sylvia’s happiness, an act of stubborn pride from Helen and a source of bemusement to the rest of the family, none of whom tackles it, and even more mystifying to outsiders. No reservations about this one; it all hangs together beautifully.

Swift Press: London 9781800757325 304 pages Hardback


Discover more from A Life in Books

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

3 thoughts on “This Is Not About Us by Allegra Goodman: ‘This has nothing to do with cake’  ”

Leave a comment ...

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.