Mrs Gaskell and Me by Nell Stevens: A little light relief

Cover imageI was casting around for a spot of diversion after a string of excellent but particularly dark novels when Nell Stevens’ Mrs Gaskell and Me arrived. I’d been eyeing it up for a little while, wondering if I’d enjoy it and now seemed the perfect time to find out. Stevens’ account of her doctoral research into Mrs Gaskell’s correspondence with a young man she met in Rome together with her own love story turned out to be very appealing, although perhaps not as light hearted as I’d expected.

Stevens had been struggling for a little while, trying to get a grip on her thesis, watching her fellow post-grad students, all displaying the classic signs of the PhD candidate – obsession with one’s subject, inability to talk about anyone’s else’s subject, a tendency to prickliness – but finding nothing of their passion in her own research. She’s constantly distracted by fantasies about Max, the friend she met on a creative writing course in Boston, with whom she’s fallen in apparently unrequited love. When he invites her to Paris, where he’s trying to write, she goes armed with a declaration that this can’t go on, that she adores him but can no longer see him platonically. After an awkward supper, things take a surprising turn back at Max’s apartment. Not long after, the focus of Stevens’ research becomes clear to her. Anticipating opprobrium on the publication of her biography of her dear friend Charlotte Brontë, Mrs Gaskell took herself off to Rome where she immersed herself in the English-speaking artistic community, meeting the likes of Elizabeth and Robert Barrett Browning and making the acquaintance of Charles Eliot Newton with whom she formed a deep connection. It’s this that Stevens decides to research, based on their correspondence.

Unlike Mrs Gaskell, who informed her publisher that she wanted to libel those she felt had let Brontë down, Stevens makes no bones about her book being a ‘work of imagination’, weaving imagined episodes in Rome through her own story and addressing some sections directly to Mrs Gaskell herself. I may well not have picked this book up without the Gaskell hook but I found myself rushing through these sections eager to get on and find out what was happening between Stevens and Max. There’s plenty of heartbreak here, despite the light tone, but there’s also a good deal of humour to enjoy particularly if you’ve had anything to do with academic life. I see from her biographical notes that Stevens teaches creative writing and I suspect she’s much more comfortable with that than in a literature department. I raced through her book, rooting for her all the way. Happy endings often make for dull fiction but give me a real life one any day. I hope Stevens has found hers.

18 thoughts on “Mrs Gaskell and Me by Nell Stevens: A little light relief

  1. Café Society

    I spent (lost) an hour recently listening to someone purporting to talk about Mrs Gaskell. In reality he spoke about her for roughly ten minutes and spent the other fifty tell us how brilliant he was and how everyone kept telling him how brilliant he was. Consequently, I am not really drawn to anything with Gaskell in the title at the moment but your hook about academic life does catch my attention and I may have to give Gaskell a reprieve.

    Reply
    1. Susan Osborne Post author

      Ha! My experience of academic life is second-hand but that doesnt’t sound unfamiliar. I’m not sure how much you’d learn much about Mrs Gaskell from Stevens’ book either, Ann, but she writes delightfully about her own life.

      Reply
  2. Rebecca Foster

    I enjoyed this very much last year. I thought it had just the right balance between memoir and autofiction. (Having a degree in Victorian literature meant I had the requisite interest to pick it up, though I have no particular love of Gaskell.)

    Reply
  3. Rebecca Foster

    Yes. I was less keen, though it’s still interesting. It was the randomly scattered short stories that put me off. (I passed on my copy to Elle, as it’s about writing a novel.)

    Reply
  4. naomifrisby

    I read this last year and really loved it. Have you read Nell’s piece (published on Boundless) about reading thrillers after her miscarriage? Bleak, obviously, but very good.

    Reply
    1. Susan Osborne Post author

      Actually, I found those bits a little irritating although her research was interesting. I became much more invested in Stevens’ own story which she tells well.

      Reply
  5. heavenali

    This sounds interesting, I think I might have more interest in the Mrs Gaskell than the memoir section. Having said that I am also nervous of fictionalised accounts of real people. Mrs Gaskell in Rome is a tempting idea though.

    Reply

Leave a comment ...

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.